23 skin-care products with near-perfect Amazon reviews

Insider Picks writes about products and services to help you navigate when shopping online. Insider Inc. receives a commission from our affiliate partners when you buy through our links, but our reporting and recommendations are always independent and objective.

• There are plenty of standout products hiding in plain sight on Amazon.
• Below, I've compiled a list of 23 skin care products with near-perfect reviews, plus their overall Amazon rating and what they're built to do for your skin.
• More: 19 best-selling skin-care products that Amazon customers swear by — all under $25

Have you — or anyone you've ever met — ever reached the end of Amazon page results?

To me, it sounds more like the riddle of what would happen if you were to finally reach the ends of the Earth, or beat an unbeatable video game. Does the internet break? Does time cease and then, rapidly, ominously, move backward? 

Guessing by Amazon's selection size, we aren't going to find out any time soon. Put that existential dread to bed.

The online behemoth's sheer plethora of options makes it both the most convenient place to buy what you already know you love, and one of the tougher places to apply its frequent discounts to new worthwhile buys — like skin care, which can be more expensive than it warrants thanks to beauty industry markups. 

Below, I've compiled a list of 23 solid skin-care products flying under the radar on Amazon that you may want to check out the next time you need a Vitamin C Serum and don't want to drop $100 or more on one. The following cult-favorites have hundreds — if not thousands — of five-star reviews you can vet yourself before buying, too. 

23 under-the-radar skin-care products with hundreds of near-perfect Amazon reviews:

Thayers Facial Toner

Thayers Alcohol-free Rose Petal Witch Hazel with Aloe Vera, $6.99

Overall rating: 4.5/5 stars

Five-star reviews: 8,000+

Thayers' witch hazel toner is a cult favorite of the online beauty community. It has over 10,000 five-star reviews on Amazon and is consistently one of the site's most popular skin-care products under $25. Rose water, aloe vera, and a proprietary witch hazel extract work gently and efficiently to cleanse and hydrate skin, tighten pores, and control oil production.

Thayers supposedly creates the only witch hazel products made of non-distilled extract from the witch hazel shrub, meaning they should maintain the highest levels of therapeutic tannins (mild antioxidants that nourish the skin).

Aztec Secret Indian Healing Clay

Aztec Secret Indian Healing Clay Mask, $10.95

Overall rating: 4.4/5 stars

Five-star reviews: 13,000+

This underground beauty community Holy Grail has shown up everywhere from the Sephora beauty blog to Youtube vlogs. I wrote my own love letter to it after receiving a glowing recommendation from a colleague.

It's been called the 'world's most powerful mask' and with good reason: the 100% natural calcium bentonite clay draws out all the impurities deep in your skin, and, especially if mixed with apple cider vinegar, effectively exfoliates the surface of the skin for a smoother, more even texture.

Esarora Ice Roller

Esarora Ice Roller for Face & Eye, $14.99

Overall rating: 4.6/5 stars

Five-star reviews: 1,400+

The Esarora Ice Roller is designed to shrink pores and puffiness and act as minor pain relief for migraines, sunburns, and sinus discomfort.