The 4 Democratic presidential candidates who cosponsored Bernie Sanders’ Medicare for All Senate bill either no longer support it or won’t say if they do
- The rift between the progressive and moderate Democratic presidential candidates is deepening on healthcare.
- Sen. Kamala Harris recently ignited another round of controversy on her healthcare position when she distanced herself from the Medicare for All bill that Sen. Bernie Sanders pushed in the Senate — two years after she became its first cosponsor.
- The Harris comments underscore a new, if subtle, rhetorical shift on the campaign trail among the 2020 Democrats.
- They've begun tempering their endorsement for the sweeping Sanders plan, acknowledging that eliminating private health insurance remains unpopular with voters, according to recent polling.
- Insider reached out to each of the four Sanders bill co-sponsors who are running for the presidency: Harris, and Sens. Elizabeth Warren, Cory Booker and Kirsten Gillibrand.
- The Warren, Harris and Gillibrand campaigns didn't respond, and the Booker campaign didn't say whether or not he still stood by the Sanders bill.
- Visit Business Insider's homepage for more stories.
The rift between the progressive and moderate Democratic presidential candidates is deepening on healthcare.
Sen. Kamala Harris recently ignited another round of controversy on her healthcare position when she distanced herself from the Medicare for All bill that Sen. Bernie Sanders pushed in the Senate — two years after she became its first cosponsor.
In remarks this weekend to wealthy donors at a Hamptons fundraiser, Harris said she has "not been comfortable" with the Sanders proposal, the Daily Beast first reported. Then the California senator told the Washington Post she didn't think her discomfort "was any secret."
Sanders later blasted Harris, and doubled down on his signature healthcare plan.
I don't go to the Hamptons to raise money from billionaires. If I ever visited there, I would tell them the same thing I have said for the last 30 years: We must pass a Medicare for All system to guarantee affordable health care for all, not just for those who can afford it.
— Bernie Sanders (@BernieSanders) August 19, 2019
The Harris comments underscore a new, if subtle, rhetorical shift on the campaign trail among the 2020 Democrats. They've begun tempering their endorsement for the sweeping Sanders plan, acknowledging that eliminating private health insurance remains unpopular with voters, according to recent polling.
Insider reached out to each of the four Sanders bill co-sponsors running for the presidency: Harris, and Sens. Elizabeth Warren, Cory Booker and Kirsten Gillibrand. The Warren, Harris, and Gillibrand campaigns did not respond to requests for comment asking if they stood by the Sanders bill.
The Booker campaign pointed to answers the New Jersey senator gave The New York Times on a healthcare policy survey back in June. He acknowledged he was a sponsor of the Sanders bill, but said, "the most important thing is to keep the ultimate goal in mind: affordable health care for every American, because health care is a human right."
When pressed for additional specifics, the Booker campaign did not respond to requests for comment.
At the onset of the Democratic primary, endorsing Medicare for All became a litmus test for the candidates, a way of highlighting their progressive credentials in a primary driven by party activists. But voters expressed concern with ending private health insurance, forcing some of the candidates to reevaluate their approach. Strengthening the Affordable Care Act is another idea that's proved popular with Democratic voters.
Read more: 2020 Dems grapple with how to pay for 'Medicare for All'
"What I think has happened in the Democratic primary is people recognize that some of the concerns about single-payer are not coming from special interests but the public," Neera Tanden, president of the Center for American Progress, told the Post.
Like the Green New Deal, the dynamics suggest Democrats view the Sanders Senate bill as the embodiment of a long-term vision, instead of an immediate plan to run on and fully champion.
Harris rolled out her new Medicare for All plan last month, which would allow private insurers to sell health coverage through Medicare under strict regulations, and aim to achieve universal coverage within ten years.
In the past, Booker labeled himself "a pragmatist" when it comes to healthcare reform and has stressed he would "find the immediate things we can do."
Warren still has not come out with her own healthcare plan. Though she said she was "proud" to cosponsor the Sanders bill, she's given herself some breathing room by acknowledging "there a lot of different pathways" to achieving universal healthcare. Gillibrand recently said at a Washington Post event she liked the idea of a government-run healthcare system that competes with private insurers, otherwise known as the public option.
Among the 2020 Democrats, the battle over the best way to achieve healthcare reform is just getting started.
Join the conversation about this story »
NOW WATCH: Why Venice floods every year