We test Cornetto copies from Tesco, Asda and Lidl – which one came out on top in our taste test?
JUST one cornetto, give it to me . . . The only problem, is that they’re too pricey. A recent test by consumer champions Which? magazine found that on average most ice-cream chompers actually preferred the taste of supermarket own-brand Cornetto-style fruity ice cream cones to the freezer aisle market leader. So which own brand fruity cones have got […]
JUST one cornetto, give it to me . . . The only problem, is that they’re too pricey.
A recent test by consumer champions Which? magazine found that on average most ice-cream chompers actually preferred the taste of supermarket own-brand Cornetto-style fruity ice cream cones to the freezer aisle market leader.
So which own brand fruity cones have got it licked this summer, and which ones are melting away?
Laura Stott rated a selection of own-brand berry styles compared to the frozen bestsellers, and gave her verdict and a mark out of five for each.
Tesco Ice Cream Cones
x4 £1.20 (30p per cone) tesco.co.uk
3/5
BIGGER than the original Cornetto and good packaging – my ice kept intact.
Nice treat, with vanilla and strawberry ice cream segments on top, fruity strawberry bits which had decent flavour if a bit artificial tasting, and fun meringue nibbles on top instead of nuts.
READ MORE ON ICE CREAM
The ice cream and cone are both a bit sweet, and the meringue adds sugar.
Cone was only half-filled with ice cream. But a crowd-pleaser – and great price.
Lidl Bon Gelati Strawberry & Vanilla
x4 £1.45 (24p per cone) www.lidl.co.uk
5/5
MY winner, this. If you like gooey, a bit messy and plenty of sauce, you will love this.
Really tasty soft whipped-style ice cream and out-standing strawberry sauce – super-fruity and loads of it.
Most read in Fabulous
The sauce runs to the bottom of the cone, not just swirled on top.
The cone was quite crumbly but when it tastes this good who cares, especially at almost a third of the price of a Wall’s Cornetto.
Larger than the original, too.
Walls Cornetto Strawberry
x4 £2.50 (62p per cone) from Walls
3/5
MARKET leader looks as good as you would expect.
Nifty foil-wrap with overlap on the lid makes it easy to pull off the packaging without wrecking the contents.
Lovely vanilla ice cream with strawberry segments, nuts, a thick band of chocolate and crisp wafer cone.
The strawberry ice cream was delicious and went all the way to the chocolate at the bottom.
But this cone is a little small – and very expensive.
M&S Strawberry
x4 £1.70 (42p per cone) in stores
3/5
UNWRAPPED well, and so pretty with pastel-coloured strawberry ice cream and generous fruit sauce.
Only one flavour of ice cream but you get a lot, all the way down the cone.
Soft, whippy feel, with proper flavour.
Strawberry sauce is tastiest of all the cones.
Quality chocolate, too, with yummy wedge at the base.
Very nice cone, perhaps more suited to adults than kids because it looks a bit plain – but enjoyable.
Gianni’s Raspberry and Cream Cones
x 4 £1.69 (42p per cone) aldi.co.uk
4/5
THESE fruity raspberry cones from Aldi are quite the showstopper, with oodles of richly coloured berry ice cream, big dollops of sauce and a sprinkling of freeze-dried fruit on top.
They look like a proper summer treat and the taste doesn’t disappoint either.
The ice cream is good quality, with a whippy, soft texture, nice tart sauce and a crispy cone with good chocolate content. Ideal for a special treat but they are a bit pricey.
Asda Strawberry Cones
x4 £1.20 (30p per cone) asda.co.uk
4/5
A BASIC, no-frills fruit offering but none the worse for it, as the ingredients are excellent quality for the price.
It is simple strawberry ice cream and fruit sauce but when you tuck in, the ice cream is top quality.
This is proper old-fashioned ice cream, not too soft and very creamy.
The cone is top notch, too – crispy, crunchy and filled all the way to the bottom.
Lacks dazzle but that doesn’t matter at this price
Sainsbury’s strawberry & vanilla
x4 £1.25 (31p per cone) sainsburys.co.uk
THIS lot gain extra marks for the waffle cone, which was crunchy, tasty and very good quality.
The ice cream wasn’t bad, either, although there was much more vanilla than strawberry on top and going down into the cone.
The fruit flavour was a bit lacklustre and needed more depth.
Quick to melt, too.
Good amounts of chocolate, though, and all in all very little to complain about for the price.
Co-op strawberry & vanilla
x4 £1.90 (47p per cone) in stores
2/5
THESE looked very unexciting.
The chocolate coating was cracked and peeling, the cone was thin and flimsy and the topping looked dull and plain, with just basic strawberry-and- vanilla ice cream and strawberry sauce.
What about the nuts? However, these cones did deliver on taste.
Read More on The Sun
The ice cream was creamy and fruity and the chocolate was delicious.
Marked down for price and poor cone quality.