All Stars Arabella was ‘told to pick Chris’ by Love Island bosses claim fans in wild conspiracy theory
LOVE Island bosses meddled in Arabella’s decision to pick Chris in last night’s explosive coupling-up ceremony, claim fans in a wild new theory.
All Stars super-sleuths suspect the model was “told to pick” the influencer – despite her previous history with Toby Aromolaran, 24.
Earlier in the day, Love Island All Stars fans were left disgusted by Arabella’s “rank” sex confession after she admitted to sleeping with footballer Toby – and were therefore convinced he would be her top pick.
Yet when Arabella, 32, selected Chris, 33 – despite Tyler, 28, also entering the South Africa compound as a bombshell – they admitted they had their “conspiracy hats on.”
Her decision also triggered a shock double eviction – and meant Demi and Luis were dumped straight away.
One suspicious fan took to X to muse: “Now we know why Arabella picked Chris .. because she was told to. Because if she picked Toby or Josh, it would have meant evicting one of the Georgia’s .. and they could have that, could they.”
A second agreed and added: “They definitely told Arabella to couple with Chris instead of Toby,” as a third mused: “Arabella picking Chris is so random.”
A Love Island loyal then wrote: “Arabella stole Chris?! She went safe. She wanted Toby.”
One then posted: “Why did this feel set up by producers? I’ve hardly seen Arabella and Chris talk… Of course they don’t want Georgia out just yet its pretty obvious She would have picked Toby. Or maybe its just me?”
Meanwhile, over on Reddit the feeling was the same.
A show fan continued: “Nah my conspiracy hat is on: The producers told Arabella to steal Chris so that they could get rid of the Luis/Demi storyline asap.”
Their speculation was heightened after Arabella left All Stars fans confused when she claimed she didn’t know Chris – despite previously sharing a villa with him back in 2019.
Earlier this week, we reported how Arabella “broke her silence” on her break-up with Man City defender Ruben Dias.
She signed up to the dating show after being dumped by footballer following their New year getaway.
The star’s family and friends, who are now looking after her Instagram page during her time in the South Africa compound, have since added more detail.
As a Love Island fan quizzed: “Is she still with her bf?” they replied: “No it just didn’t work out.
“She’s back in the villa because she really wants to find the one.”
Listen to all our Love Island podcast episodes:
LOVE ISLAND ALL STARS
Meet all the islanders on the latest series of Love Island
- Hannah Elizabeth – Love Island 2015
- Georgia Steel – Love Island 2018
- Georgia Harrison – Love Island 2017
- Chris Taylor – Love Island 2019
- Anton Danyluk – Love Island 2019
- Mitch Taylor – Love Island 2023
- Demi Jones – Love Island 2020
- Liberty Poole – Love Island 2021
- Jake Cornish – Love Island 2021
- Kaz Kamwi – Love Island 2021
- Luis Morrison – Love Island 2015
- Toby Aromolaran – Love Island 2021
- Callum Jones – Love Island 2020
- Joshua Ritchie – Love Island 2015
- Arabella Chi – Love Island 2019
- Molly Smith – Love Island 2020