Amex Membership Rewards vs. Chase Ultimate Rewards: Which should you choose in 2024?

The offers and details on this page may have updated or changed since the time of publication. See our article on Business Insider for current information.

Affiliate links for the products on this page are from partners that compensate us and terms apply to offers listed (see our advertiser disclosure with our list of partners for more details). However, our opinions are our own. See how we rate credit cards to write unbiased product reviews.

The information for the following product(s) has been collected independently by Business Insider: Chase Freedom Flex®, Amex EveryDay® Credit Card. The details for these products have not been reviewed or provided by the issuer.

• Chase Ultimate Rewards and American Express Membership Rewards are the most popular credit card reward programs.
• Both let you redeem rewards for cash back, gift cards, and the most valuable option: Travel.
• Amex has more travel partners, but Chase's selection of partners is better for many U.S. travelers. 
• Read Business Insider's guide to the best rewards credit cards.

If you're looking for a card that earns you rewards on all your purchases, you have no shortage of options. You can choose a luxury travel rewards card like The Platinum Card® from American Express, which offers perks like airport lounge access, elite hotel status, and annual airline fee credits**. You can also choose a card with a much lower annual fee and more basic benefits like the popular Chase Sapphire Preferred Card.

The Amex Platinum Card and Chase Sapphire Preferred earn points in two different programs — American Express Membership Rewards and Chase Ultimate Rewards®, respectively. Chase Ultimate Rewards and American Express Membership Rewards are easily the two most popular flexible programs available today, but there are differences in the cards that accrue these points and how the programs themselves work for consumers.

So how do you decide which program makes the most sense for you? If you're in the market for a new travel credit card but can't decide between Chase points and Amex points, this guide should make the decision much easier.

Chase Ultimate Rewards Overview

Chase Ultimate Rewards points are flexible rewards you can earn with top Chase credit cards, including:

• Chase Sapphire Preferred ($95 annual fee)
• Chase Sapphire Reserve ($550 annual fee)
• Ink Business Preferred Credit Card (small-business credit card with a $95 annual fee)

Note that you can also earn Chase Ultimate Rewards with cash-back credit cards like the Chase Freedom Flex® and Chase Freedom Unlimited, but these points don't transfer to airline and hotel partners unless you have an annual-fee Chase Ultimate Rewards card.

When you start earning Chase Ultimate Rewards points, you'll immediately notice that there are many ways to redeem them. You can cash in points for gift cards and merchandise, and you can even use them to stop on Amazon.com or the Apple Store. You can also redeem rewards for experiences and travel through the Chase Travel℠ Portal. 

With premier travel cards like the Chase Sapphire Reserve, Chase Sapphire Preferred® Card, and Ink Business Preferred card, you can also transfer points 1:1 to popular airline and hotel partners. This means you'll get 1,000 airline or hotel points for every 1,000 points you transfer to Chase partners.

Chase Ultimate Rewards points can be especially valuable when you transfer points to airline and hotel partners. For example, you could transfer points to the World of Hyatt program and stay in a luxury hotel that might cost $1,000 or more per night.

You could also transfer points to an airline partner to redeem for a business or first-class flight.

Either way, one of the main benefits of Chase Ultimate Rewards points is that you have the option to explore all the rewards opportunities with Chase hotel and airline transfer partners if you have a travel credit card like the Sapphire Preferred.

However, you don't have to redeem these rewards for travel. You can also cash in points for statement credits or gift cards at a rate of 1 cent per point, or even for merchandise through the Chase portal.

Chase Ultimate Rewards: Pros

• You can get more value for your points when you redeem them for travel through the Chase portal. With the Chase Sapphire Reserve, for example, you'll get 50% more travel when you use points in the portal. With the Chase Sapphire Preferred and Ink Business Preferred, on the other hand, you get 25% more travel.
• Chase Ultimate Rewards cards offer significant sign-up bonuses that let you rack up points quickly. Chase cards come with generous welcome bonuses. This includes the Chase Ink Business Preferred, which gives you 120,000 bonus points after spending $8,000 on purchases in the first three months from account opening.
• Chase lets you pool points with a partner or spouse who lives at your same address. This is a huge benefit for families who want to pool all their points together to maximize redemptions.
• Chase lets you pool all your points in a premier travel credit card account before you redeem. For example, you can pool points earned with the Chase Freedom Flex® or Chase Freedom Unlimited into your Chase Sapphire Preferred or Chase Sapphire Reserve account to get 1:1 transfers to airlines and hotels. 
• Chase's new Pay Yourself Back feature gives you great value when you use points to cover dining and groceries. Chase introduced the Pay Yourself Back feature during the coronavirus pandemic to give cardholders a non-travel option for using points. It lets you redeem your points on eligible cards to cover dining, grocery, home improvement, and eligible charity purchases at a rate of 1.25 or 1.50 cents per point, depending on the card you have.

Chase Ultimate Rewards: Cons

• Premier Chase travel credit cards all charge an annual fee. The only real "downside" of Chase Ultimate Rewards points is the fact that all the top cards in this program charge an annual fee.

American Express Membership Rewards Overview

This brings us to the American Express Membership Rewards program, which is similar to the Chase Ultimate Rewards with a few key differences.

One thing you'll notice right away with this program is the fact that there are so many Amex cards you can use to earn rewards. You can opt for a premium travel card like the Amex Platinum Card if you're willing to pay the hefty $695 annual fee , but you can also earn Membership Rewards points with a card like the Amex EveryDay® Credit Card, which doesn't charge an annual fee.

Once again, there are plenty of ways to redeem rewards in this program. With American Express Membership Rewards, you can pay with points at checkout with merchants like Amazon.com, Boxed.com, and Dell.com.

You can also redeem rewards for gift cards or shop for merchandise through the Amex website. Finally, you have the option to book travel directly through American Express Travel, including hotels, airfare, cruises, and travel packages.

The American Express Membership Rewards program includes the following transfer partners:

Like the Chase Ultimate Rewards program, American Express Membership Rewards offers the most bang for your buck when you transfer points to airline and hotel partners. However, you don't have to use these rewards for travel at all, since there are so many other ways to cash in points for gift cards or merchandise.

American Express Membership Rewards: Pros

• Redeem your rewards for superior travel redemptions, including transfers to airlines and hotels. One of the biggest advantages of the Amex Membership Rewards program is the fact there are so many ways to cash in your points. However, you'll get the most bang for your buck with transfers to airlines for redemptions in premium cabins.
• You can earn American Express Membership Rewards without paying an annual fee. Several cards let you earn Membership Rewards without an annual fee, including the Amex EveryDay® Credit Card and The Blue Business® Plus Credit Card from American Express.
• Some cards offer bonus points back when you redeem points for airfare. The Business Platinum Card® from American Express gives you 35% in bonus points when you redeem points for airfare on American Express Travel (up to 500,000 points back each calendar year).
• You can use points to bid for flight upgrades. American Express offers the option to use points to bid for upgrades on flights you've already booked.

American Express Membership Rewards: Cons

• Redemption values aren't that great for merchandise, shopping, and gift cards. Unlike Chase Ultimate Rewards, which typically lets you get 1 cent per point in value for gift cards or statement credits, Amex redemptions aren't that generous. You'll normally get 0.5 cents per point to 1 cent per point for gift cards and cash, and up to 0.7 cents per point for merchandise from select retailers. Other redemption values can vary.
• You can't pool points with a spouse or partner. This program doesn't let you pool points in a single account with a partner or spouse, although all the points you earn across multiple cards will collect in a single Membership Rewards account.

 

Choosing Between Chase Points and Amex Points

If you can't decide between Chase Ultimate Rewards and American Express Membership Rewards, there are some serious questions you should be asking yourself. For example:

• Which program has transfer partners I'll actually use?
• Which credit card in each program has additional benefits I'll take advantage of?
• Am I willing to pay an annual fee on a credit card?
• Do I want to pool points with a partner or spouse, then redeem them together?

Most of the time, the best rewards program for you is the one that has the transfer partners you'll actually use. In that sense, Chase Ultimate Rewards tends to come out ahead, since it has popular transfer partners most Americans are familiar with, including Southwest Rapid Rewards, World of Hyatt, and United MileagePlus, to name a few.

On the other hand, American Express Membership Rewards has more transfer partners in total, including ones that can be hard to transfer points to otherwise. If you're a huge Delta Air Lines flyer, for example, you may want to stick with Membership Rewards and also pick up a co-branded Delta credit card to get benefits like a free checked bag and priority boarding.

If you really just want to redeem rewards for cash back or gift cards, Chase Ultimate Rewards is a better deal. That's because you'll typically get 1 cent per point in value for these redemptions, whereas American Express Membership Rewards redemptions for cash, merchandise, and gift cards are typically worth less than that. And with the Pay Yourself Back feature on certain Chase cards, your points are extra valuable toward dining, groceries, and home-improvement purchases.