Fact Check: Is There An Anti-Hate Crime Bill Specifically For Black Americans?
Source: HOSSEIN FATEMI / Getty
Black Americans remain the most frequent victims of racially motivated hate crimes in the U.S. A 2023 study published by the Center for the Study of Hate and Extremism at California State University San Bernardino found that Black people were targeted in over 20% of hate crimes in major U.S. cities last year, the highest proportion among all groups.
Although the overall rate of anti-Black hate crimes fell by 6% from previous years, this decrease was uneven, with many cities and states experiencing record or near-record levels of such crimes. Historically, African Americans have faced the highest rate of hate crimes, a trend that continued into 2022.
In the ongoing battle against hate and discrimination, legislation plays a crucial role in safeguarding vulnerable communities. While existing hate crime laws provide broad protections, there are pressing questions about whether more targeted measures are necessary. Specifically, is there an anti-hate crime bill designed exclusively for Black people, and should there be one?
Is there a specific anti-hate crime for Black People?
Currently, there is no anti-hate crime bill in the United States that exclusively targets crimes against Black individuals. However, as political pundit and SiriusXM talk show host Reecie Colbert noted in an X post shared Sept. 2., the DOJ began prosecuting hate crimes against Black people shortly after the Civil Rights Act of 1968 was established.
I did this deep dive into federal hate crimes on the basis of race to put an end to the disinformation around the COVID-19 Hate Crimes Act (aka "the Asians got a bill") and the bizarre claim that we don't have hate crimes legislation for Black victims of hate crimes. The Civil… pic.twitter.com/FcCjiygc8O
— Reecie @BlackWomenViews (@ReecieColbert) September 2, 2024
The act is best known for its provisions related to housing. It prohibits discrimination in the sale, rental, or financing of housing based on race, color, religion, or national origin. This was a significant step in combating racial segregation and ensuring equal access to housing opportunities. The law was later extended to combat discrimination to include not only race and color but also religion and national origin. Further amendments would expand these protections to include gender, disability and familial status.
Hate crime legislation, such as Matthew Shepard and James Byrd, Jr. Hate Crimes Prevention Act of 2009, provides protections against crimes motivated by race, gender or sexual orientation among other factors, according to the U.S. Department of Justice’s website. The federal law, enacted to address and prevent hate crimes, includes race as a protected category, thereby covering crimes committed against Black people.
Recently, celebrities such as Tyrese and other notable figures have criticized President Biden and Vice President Kamala Harris for focusing anti-hate crime legislation on specific communities. For instance, the COVID-19 Hate Crimes Act (2021) was created to safeguard Asian American and Pacific Islander communities during the pandemic. The law mandated the appointment of a hate crimes coordinator at the Department of Justice and directed the FBI to fast-track investigations of COVID-19-related hate crimes affecting these groups. However, there are also legislative efforts aimed at addressing issues that disproportionately impact Black communities.
Tyrese calls out Joe Biden and Kamala Harris for signing a hate crime bill to protect Asians but skipping over Black and Latino people who are being killed. pic.twitter.com/v4Ltb9LQEW
— The Art Of Dialogue (@ArtOfDialogue_) September 1, 2024
One such bill is the Emmett Till Antilynching Act, signed into law in 2022 under the Biden administration. The legislation designates lynching as a federal hate crime, making it a distinct federal offense. It was enacted to address both the historical and ongoing violence of lynching, which has predominantly targeted Black Americans. The law imposes criminal penalties—including fines, imprisonment for up to 30 years, or both—on individuals who conspire to commit a hate crime resulting in death or serious bodily injury.
At the state level, hate crime laws vary significantly, with some states having specific provisions to address crimes targeting racial minorities. However, no national legislation focuses solely on hate crimes against Black individuals.
Should there be a specific anti-hate crime bill for Black People?
The question of whether a specialized bill is necessary requires a nuanced examination of existing protections, the prevalence of hate crimes, and the effectiveness of current laws. Current hate crime laws already encompass racial discrimination, offering protection to Black individuals. However, the enforcement and application of these laws can vary, leading to potential gaps in addressing hate crimes effectively.
Despite the existing legal framework, there are concerns about the efficacy of hate crime legislation. Inconsistent application, underreporting, and challenges in prosecution can undermine the impact of current laws. A 2023 series of evidence-based research reports, supported by the National Institute of Justice (NIJ), uncovered crucial data contributing to the issue of hate crime underreporting. Key findings included: the reluctance of hate crime victims to engage with law enforcement; challenges faced by both victims and law enforcement agencies in recognizing and classifying certain incidents as hate crimes; a substantial shortfall in hate crime reporting across law enforcement agencies of all sizes; and inconsistencies in hate crime definitions across different jurisdictions. A more targeted approach might address these issues by providing clearer guidelines and ensuring better resource allocation.
A bill specifically designed to protect Black individuals could offer both practical and symbolic benefits. Practically, it could provide additional resources and focus on addressing racial violence more effectively. Symbolically, it would demonstrate a strong commitment to confronting the unique challenges faced by Black communities. However, until such legislation is enacted, it is essential to utilize and strengthen existing protections. Lawmakers must diligently enforce these laws and ensure that those who violate them are held accountable.
SEE ALSO:
‘Blacks Must Sit At The Back…’: Racist Anti-Kamala Harris Signs Spotted At Denver Bus Stops
The post Fact Check: Is There An Anti-Hate Crime Bill Specifically For Black Americans? appeared first on NewsOne.