How Vance and Trump’s Lies About Springfield, Ohio Continue to Unravel

Is there any evidence or credible reports of migrants stealing and eating pets in Springfield, Ohio?

No, according to local and state authorities. Per the office of the Springfield city manager: “In response to recent rumors alleging criminal activity by the immigrant population in our city, we wish to clarify that there have been no credible reports or specific claims of pets being harmed, injured, or abused by individuals within the immigrant community.”

Springfield police have received no reports of stolen or eaten pets, and no credible media investigations have been able to find any evidence of it, either.

Ohio’s Republican governor, Mike DeWine, has also debunked the rumors. “Look, there’s a lot of garbage on the internet and, you know, this is a piece of garbage that was simply not true. There’s no evidence of this at all,” he said Sunday on ABC’s This Week.

What about J.D. Vance and Trump’s purported evidence?

Vance continues to be a leading proponent of numerous incendiary claims about the Haitian migrant community in Springfield. He has promoted the pet-eating rumors, even as they were debunked by state and local officials and media organizations, and over the past week he has added his own fuel to the fire — citing purported first-hand reports his office has received from constituents which support the allegations. When pressed to put forward actual evidence, however, he has not. And during an interview with CNN’s Dana Bash on Sunday morning, he seemed to admit that he and Trump were creating stories for media attention:

Vance claims he and Trump have to "create stories" about migrants eating cats and dogs "so that the American media actually pays attention to the suffering of the American people."

There is then some awkward dead air as Bash tries to highlight the absurdity of what he just said pic.twitter.com/IN26ZGYsvE

— Aaron Rupar (@atrupar) September 15, 2024

In the same interview, he repeatedly cited reports from constituents as proof, and specifically said some of those reports were verifiable — but offered no evidence to back that up:

wow -- Dana Bash with a brutal fact-check of JD Vance after Vance smears *legal* Haitian immigrants in Springfield with debunked claims. Vance responds by calling what she said "disgusting" as Bash looks shocked at him making it personal. pic.twitter.com/gbjDRjS2nF

— Aaron Rupar (@atrupar) September 15, 2024

After the interview, Vance said in an X post that it was a “dishonest smear” to say he admitted creating the stories. “I didn’t invent constituents complaining about this,” he wrote, “we did help create the media focus on their complaints.”

Trump, during the September 10 presidential debate, was pressed to provide evidence for the pet-eating rumors in Springfield. He responded that he had seen “people on television” making the claims, but it’s not clear who he was talking about. No purported victims or first-hand witnesses of such incidents have come forward publicly.

How did the pet-eating rumor originally get started?

According to an investigation by Newsguard Reality Check, the rumor appears to have started in early September with a now deleted post in a private Facebook group called “Springfield Ohio Crime and Information” where a resident posted a “warning to all about our beloved pets & those around us” in which she said:

My neighbor informed me that her daughters friend had lost her cat. … One day she came home from work, as soon as she stepped out of her car, looked towards a neighbors house, where Haitians live, & saw her cat hanging from a branch, like you’d do a deer for butchering, & they were carving it up to eat. I’ve been told they are doing this to dogs …

Newsguard contacted the author of the post, Erika Lee, and the neighbor who she heard the story from, Kimberly Newton:

“I’m not sure I’m the most credible source because I don’t actually know the person who lost the cat,” Newton said about the rumor she had passed on to her neighbor[.] Newton explained to NewsGuard that the cat owner was “an acquaintance of a friend” and that she heard about the supposed incident from that friend, who, in turn, learned about it from “a source that she had.” Newton added: “I don’t have any proof.” …

Lee, who described herself to NewsGuard as a Democrat who supports Donald Trump, told us that she was “shocked” to see Trump repeat the claim that she had made in a private Facebook group. “Honestly, it blew me away,” Lee said. “I didn’t think that any of this would explode to the presidency.” … As for how the story has shed a negative light on the thousands of Haitian migrants who have settled in Springfield, Lee said she was “just trying to inform people, you know, again, not saying Haitians as a whole [are] bad.”

A screenshot of Lee’s post with her name redacted was shared on X on September 5 and the story quickly went viral among conservatives until it was eventually promoted by J.D. Vance and Donald Trump.

“It just exploded into something I didn’t mean to happen,” Lee told NBC News, emphasizing her regret and fears since posting the message:

“I’m not a racist,” she said through heavy emotion, adding that her daughter is half Black and she herself is mixed race and a member of the LGBTQ community. “Everybody seems to be turning it into that, and that was not my intent.” … Lee said she pulled her daughter out of school and is now worried about her safety with so much attention on her family. She is also concerned for the safety of the Haitian community, which she said she did not intend to villainize en masse. “I feel for the Haitian community,” she said. “If I was in the Haitians’ position, I’d be terrified, too, worried that somebody’s going to come after me because they think I’m hurting something that they love and that, again, that’s not what I was trying to do.”

What about claims migrants in Springfield have taken geese or other animals?

Since March, there have been a couple of reports made to local authorities alleging that people of Haitian descent had taken wild birds from Springfield parks. The authorities could not confirm the allegations. Reports the Associated Press:

[Ohio Department of Natural Resources] records show that in March someone reported seeing three Haitian men grab a live duck and a goose and put them in a trash bag. The officer said the witness did not provide any information that could identify a suspect and said he monitored the area but found no evidence of a crime. In August, a caller reported seeing four people of Haitian descent each carrying a goose before they left in a car, Springfield police records show. The wildlife officer to whom the case was referred initially was unable to reach the caller but later made contact and found nothing supporting the story.

Last month, one Springfield resident told the city commission that Haitians were grabbing ducks at a park, while another resident said immigrants had swiped farm animals and picked up roadkill. Neither made clear whether they had witnessed these things.

And neither of those people’s allegations have been verified.

NPR reports that some of the animal-eating claims regarding migrants in Springfield are also linked to neo-Nazis:

The now-refuted claim appears to have gotten its start online in early August, when a user on the far-right social platform Gab with the screen name “bri ory” commented on photos of members of the white supremacist neo-Nazi group Blood Tribe marching through Springfield protesting Haitian migrants and carrying swastika flags. The commenter claimed that “once haitians swarm into a town animals start to disappear.”

This post has been updated.