Casey’s third time in the villa says it all – Love Island All Stars needs a rest, says Jessie Wynter
LOVE Island star Jessie Wynter has slammed this year’s All Stars series after watching Casey O’Gorman in the villa for a third time.
Casey has made another comeback to the ITV2 show as a bombshell but Jessie thinks his return signals that it’s time for “a break”.
The Aussie beauty appeared in Love Island alongside Casey during his first stint, watched him on All Stars last year and cannot believe he is back again.
Speaking to The Sun on behalf of Slotscalendar, Jessie said she feels this year’s All Stars series ‘isn’t giving fans what they want’ as a result.
Jessie, 28, said: “I think it’s very early on but I don’t think it’s hitting the same as last year.
“They use the title All Star. Casey’s been in the villa three times.
“I thought All Stars was meant to be a big hurrah, people we haven’t seen for a while?
“Love Island producers, what’s going on here?”
Casey first appeared in Love Island in 2023, before returning for the 2024 All Stars series.
The 28-year-old has once again strolled back into the South African villa as an early bombshell.
Upon his return, Casey immediately came under fire from Love Island alumni and new housemate Kaz Crossley.
Kaz let rip at Casey and accused him of treating Love Island girls badly, including her close friend Georgia Harrison.
Jessie says: “Casey does bring the drama.
“Since he’s left the villa, he has been hooking up with other islanders so he’s giving Ex Island.
“Where he goes the drama follows and I think the producers love that.”
But speaking about the future of the show, she added: “I think the fact that Casey has gone into All Stars two times in a row says enough.
“I think next year, if they want it to be a big success, they almost do need to give it a rest.
“It’s called All Stars. We want to see an All Stars cast rather than scrounge islanders together and put them all in there.
“It’s not what people want to see.”
Love Island All Stars 2025 official line-up
Love Island All Stars is back on TV for season 2.
Here we take you through the line-up of all the Islanders who are in the villa so far.
- Scott Thomas – season 2 (2016).
- Marcel Somerville – season 3 (2017) – OUT
- India Reynolds – season 2 (2017) – OUT
- Gabby Allen – season 3 (2017).
- Elma Pazar – season 5 (2019) – born in 1993.
- Curtis Pritchard – season 5 (2019).
- Kaz Crossley – season 5 (2019).
- Olivia Hawkins – season 10 (2023) – OUT
- Nas Majeed – season 6 (2020).
- Luca Bish – season 8 (2022).
- Catherine Agbaje – season 10 (2023).
- Ronnie Vint – season 11 (2024).
Bombshells
Each series brings with it a string of hot single bombshells making their epic entrance into the villa.
Here’s who has joined the villa so far:
- Ekin-Su Cülcüloğlu – season 8 (2022).
- Casey O’Gorman – season 9 (2023) and All Stars (2024).
- Ron Hall – season 9 (2023).
- Tina Stinnes – season 2 (2016).
- Grace Jackson – season 11 (2024).
- Harriet Blackmore – season 11 (2024).
- Montel McKenzie – season 10 (2024).
Jessie is still in a relationship with Will Young, a farmer who she met on Love Island.
Satisfyingly the couple have proved Casey wrong, after he branded Jessie “fake” while they were all in the villa together.
Casey was also called a “snake” in February 2023 after he was accused of “encouraging” Will to have his head turned by Casa Amor bombshell Layla Al-Momani.
At the time, one fan raged: “Casey moving like a snake I see Lmaoo.”
Another added: “Casey is egging on Will.”
This year, Casey has coupled up with 2017 islander Gabby Allen.
However, earlier this week fans were convinced Casey already “wanted out” of his romance with the blonde beauty.
- Love Island All Stars can be watched on ITV2/ ITVX