Should all 50 states eliminate income tax? Understanding the real trade-offs

During the COVID-19 pandemic, millions of Americans packed up and moved — chasing sunshine, freedom and, let’s be honest, a lower tax bill. Fleeing from New York to Florida and California to Texas, one thing has become clear over the past five years.  People decide where to live in part to minimize their tax bill.

When it comes to state income taxes, the differences across America are glaring and often political. The question practically asks itself: Should all 50 states eliminate income tax altogether? Can states afford to eliminate taxes altogether? How do some states do it when others charge double-digit taxes?

Let’s dig in, not as some utopian fantasy, but as a serious look at how zero-income-tax states operate, why people are flocking there and why many blue states won’t even touch the idea.

SEN RICK SCOTT, REP BYRON DONALDS: TRUMP AND BESSENT'S IRS REFORM: LET’S END JOB-KILLING POLICIES

Why Some States Have Zero Income Tax And Some Don’t

As of 2025, there are nine states that do not impose a general state income tax on wages and earned income: Alaska, Florida, Nevada, New Hampshire, South Dakota, Tennessee, Texas, Washington and Wyoming. Technically, New Hampshire, until 2025, taxed interest and dividends, but it repealed that levy as of January 1, making it more of a "no income tax" state across the board.

Why can those states do without collecting income taxes? It’s usually because they lean heavily on alternative revenue sources:

Because they can’t wring extra funds from paychecks, zero-income-tax states must be disciplined in their budgets and accountable in their priorities.

Why Some States Charge 10% Or Higher Income Taxes

At the other extreme, several states have very steep top marginal income tax rates. For example:

Those rates exist because those states demand a certain scale of public services (transportation, housing subsidies, social welfare, public universities, Medicaid expansions) and they believe in progressive taxation to fund them. The logic is: the more you make, the more you contribute. This means, between top federal tax rates and state income tax rates, top earners work more than 6 months out of the year for the Government.

But, there’s a tipping point. Once high earners migrate, or corporations relocate, the tax base shrinks. That’s why many states flirt with caps, deductions, or flat tax proposals — trying to balance revenue needs and competitiveness.

How a Zero–Income-Tax States Really Operate — The Trade-offs

Zero income tax sounds glamorous, but it comes with trade-offs.

Why Blue States Tend to Be More Onerous

When you look at "blue" states versus "red" states, patterns emerge:

Simply put, the more a state leans blue, the more it leans into taxing income to support more expansive government.

CLICK HERE FOR MORE FOX NEWS OPINION

Should Every State Abolish Income Tax?

In principle, a zero-income-tax world appeals to fiscal conservatives and mobile capital. But, the reality for most states is harsher. Many rely on income tax as a stable backbone of their revenue structure. Eliminating it would force painful cuts or enormous hikes in sales/property tax.

For a few states with unique advantages and natural resource wealth (like Alaska), booming tourism (Florida), or aggressive growth (Texas and Nevada) the no-income-tax model is viable. But, for states with dense populations, expensive infrastructure needs, or large social service commitments, it’s going to be a very difficult leap.

While it’s not practical for all 50 states to zero out income tax today, we should push toward flattening and reducing top rates and making states more competitive financially. Red states have paved the path that it’s clear provides an advantage with fewer penalties on work, more incentives to stay and invest, and more freedom for taxpayers to decide how to allocate their dollars.

In the future, states will continue to compete for talent. Blue states that cling to 10% or higher marginal rates risk alienating their talent, their retirees and inviting flight risk. The capitalism of individual states will continue to bubble over the next decade and what you are taxed will continue to be front and center when you decide where to work and live.