Добавить новость
ru24.net
World News in Dutch
Декабрь
2016

Obama cozied up to China and battled Putin. Trump is doing the exact opposite.

0
Vox 

Get ready for some turbulence.

President Barack Obama has spent his two terms in office working to build closer ties with China while seeking to isolate and punish Vladimir Putin’s Russia.

Eight years later, Moscow is subject to painful US sanctions and continued public criticism from Obama and his aides. Beijing is a key economic partner that has at times served as a conduit to the rogue regime in North Korea.

That owes to a fairly different pattern of behavior. Russia’s 2014 invasion of Ukraine, 2015 bombing campaign in Syria, and 2016 hack of the US election convinced the administration that Russia was fundamentally a threat to the international order — a power unwilling to play by the rules. Despite its aggressive moves in the East and South China Sea, Beijing has been far less confrontational, and far more willing to negotiate with the West in good faith on long-range issues like climate change.

Team Trump sees things totally differently.

President-elect Donald Trump sees Putin not as a threat to Western norms, but as a tough and capable leader and potential partner in fighting radical Islam. China, in his eyes, is a threat to the US economy — responsible for the loss of massive numbers of American jobs — and a country that US presidents have been far too soft on for decades. By this analysis, Russia is the potential partner, and China the potential enemy worth confronting.

“China is the biggest state adversary in Trump’s mind,” Patrick Cronin, the senior director of the Asia-Pacific Security Program at the left-leaning Center for a New American Security, tells Vox. “It's not Russia. It's China.”

The differing world views have been on public display in recent days. Obama used his press conference at the White House on Friday to suggest Putin was connected to his country’s cyberattacks against the US and belittled Russia. "They are a smaller country, they are a weaker country, their economy doesn't produce anything that people want to buy except for oil and gas and arms, they don't innovate,” he said. On China, he recommended respect for diplomatic tradition, cautioning against Trump’s indications that he would consider dropping Washington’s “One China” policy, the diplomatic understanding that has underpinned US-Chinese relations for decades.

Trump, by contrast, has publicly castigated the CIA for its assertion that Russia ran a sustained hacking campaign designed to boost his chances of winning the presidency. And he’s been unrepentant about his tradition-breaking phone call with the president of Taiwan and language on revisiting One China. Beijing has responded by saying that the countries would have “nothing to discuss” on other issues if Trump tries to deviate from One China. China also seized an unmanned US Navy drone on Friday, though it's not clear if that was a response to Trump’s recent rhetoric.

What this suggests — though, knowing Trump, we can’t be sure — is that we’re about to see a massive about-face in great power politics. Obama’s basic policy — work with China, isolate Russia —is about to be flipped on its head. The US is going to start working with Russia on a raft of issues, and start challenging China on a lot more. That could mean US policy reversals in a whole host of issues, from to Syria to climate change to the US economy, with potentially major consequences for people around the world.

Get ready, in short, for some turbulence.

Trump’s China policy is a recipe for conflict

China watchers aren’t exactly sure what Trump wants out of Beijing.

His aggressive policies — proposing to impose a massive tariff on Chinese goods, for example — could simply be the result of instinctive hawkishness. By this interpretation, Trump sees China as a threat that will only respond to the threat of force.

Conversely, he could be trying to strike a deal with what he sees as America’s biggest rival. His aggressive policy proposals and rhetoric are opening bids designed to establish a stronger negotiation position down the line.

At this point, it’s impossible to tell which of these interpretations is correct. The reason is that, in either case, Trump’s opening moves would look the same: Aggressive positions on areas where the US and China are at odds. And indeed, that’s what we’ve seen, with Trump openly talking about raising tariffs and considering the possibility of dropping One China policy.

This means increased tensions between the US and China are inevitable, at least in the short term.

“Going back three weeks, [Chinese officials] were kind of guardedly optimistic, hoping that they could flatter Trump,” Aaron Friedberg, a China scholar at Princeton University, says. “In a way, he preemptively set the tone [for conflict] by doing what he’s done.”

China appears to be responding in kind. From heated rhetoric in the official state press to the recent seizing of an underwater American drone near the Philippines, Beijing is sending signals that it won’t be pushed around.

Trump will soon be in a position to respond. And while he hasn’t specified what he’ll do, exactly, to signal strength to China, it’s almost guaranteed that he will do something, if only to show that he’s serious about taking a hard line.

“We’re going to shake this thing up, color outside the lines, challenge the orthodoxy,” Cronin says, describing how he sees the Trump attitude. “The risk acceptance of Trump is much higher than Obama, who was famously risk-averse in dealing with China.”

There are all sorts of ways that Trump could do this. Options, according to the experts, include:

  • Selling advanced weapons to other powers in East Asia, like Vietnam.
  • Boosting the US military’s training mission with its Taiwanese counterparts.
  • Escalating direct US military operations in areas of tension, like naval patrols in the South China Sea.
  • Following through, even only partially, on the campaign threat to slap tariffs on Chinese imports.

Each of these policies carries its own risk. Military measures, like arms sales or patrols, risk provoking some kind of Chinese counter-provocation — something more dangerous than merely seizing a drone. They could justify as this as a response to US moves, thus strengthening their overall position in East Asia.

“I’m worried about our long-term position in the region,” Friedberg says. “One of the things that’s concerned me about the way this has gone in the past couple weeks is that I think it’s going to enable the Chinese to put blame on the United States for doing and saying destabilizing things.”

US trade sanctions on China would directly damage the US economy, even if China doesn’t choose to respond by carrying through on its implicit threat to sell off some of the US debt that it owns.

Since we don’t fully understand the Trump administration’s thought process, we can’t be sure which of these or the many other options for hurting Beijing he’ll pick. That means we’re in a period of dangerous uncertainty on a wide variety of deeply important global issues — and, indeed, on the fundamental nature of the most important bilateral relationship in the world.

How making nice with Russia could make the rest of the world worse

Trump’s well-documented affection for Moscow could also destabilize global politics. The policies that most logically follow from his overall view of Russia would upset established alliances and create incentives for Moscow to step up some of its more troubling behavior.

The biggest and most obvious action Trump could take to ease tensions with Russia is lifting sanctions on its economy, which, along with a plunge in global oil prices, have helped tip the Russian country into a recession since 2015. The sanctions were slapped on Russia in 2014 in response to its annexation of Crimea, a peninsula on Ukraine's Black Sea coast, and its backing of pro-Russia separatists in eastern Ukraine.

Lifting sanctions is something that can be done with ease — a president can lift sanctions by executive order, which means they be done without Congress. Its also an attractive option for Trump because sanctions are a prime example of a policy that has both significant material effects and enormous symbolic value: They’ve not only put a serious strain on Russian banks and oil companies, they’ve also been the leading contributor to contemporary anti-American sentiment in the country. So lifting sanctions is a perfect way to turn over a new leaf in US-Russian relations.

Russia analysts say there’s a significant chance that Trump will lift sanctions shortly after taking office, but as with everything involving him, there’s always the caveat that his attitudes could change. He's already publicly mentioned that he’ll “look at” lifting sanctions, and his nominee for secretary of state, Exxon Mobil CEO Rex Tillerson, criticized them in 2014 after the measures led to the collapse of a multi-billion Arctic energy deal with Moscow.

Lifting sanctions won’t just provide an economic boost to Russia; it will also implicitly endorse its expansionist activities in Ukraine. Russia could in turn feel empowered to meddle in other countries with impunity. The consequences of this, much like those of Trump’s China policy shifts, are unknown — maybe they’d be nothing. But saying “we’re fine with you annexing territory” is certainly a dangerous signal to send to a leader as revanchist as Putin.

The second major opportunity for creating bridges with Russia is over the proxy war between the US and Russia in Syria. Russia’s air campaigns on behalf of Syrian President Bashar al-Assad since autumn of 2015 have helped reverse the dynamics of the conflict there, putting US-backed rebels against the Assad regime on their heels. The onetime opposition stronghold of Aleppo is almost entirely under government control, and Assad’s likelihood of staying in power in Syria is growing by the day.

The fact that it appears that Russia may have effectively “won” the proxy war for the future of Syria as Trump enters office might sound like a bad place to make a deal, but in fact it could end up being just the opposite. That’s because it would eliminate the biggest difference between the US and Russia — what to do about Assad — and then bring their putatively shared interests of defeating ISIS in Iraq and Syria back into the foreground.

“If Assad really is successful in wiping out the rebels, in a way, it makes the question of the differences in US and Russian approaches moot,” Yoshiko Herrera, a political scientist at the University of Wisconsin-Madison who specializes in Russia, says.

Both the US and Russia have a national security interest in wiping out ISIS, and that’s what makes the scenario ripe for deals. Russia’s commitment to the cause could also relieve Trump of some of the burden of having a military presence in the region should the US and Russia both decide to invest in a sustained campaign against ISIS in the region.

US-Russian cooperation in Syria wouldn’t be without enormous challenges. Trump would receive huge pushback from critics in both parties who believe it would be unconscionable to allow the brutal Assad regime, stained with the blood of countless war crimes, to stay in power.

The Pentagon and CIA, meanwhile, could balk at the thought of sharing intelligence in the Middle East in light of mounting evidence that Russia used cyberattacks in a bid to tip the US election.

The third major domain in which Trump can relax relations with Russia is related to how he approaches NATO. The Cold War-era military alliance was formed to protect Europe from the Soviet Union, and today one of its roles is serving as a bulwark against Russian influence and expansionism. If Trump continues to criticize NATO or takes steps to substantively reduce American support for the alliance, that’s automatically beneficial to Russia.

“Previous to Trump, every incoming president has been a supporter and defender of NATO,” Herrera says. She believes that just with rhetoric, Trump can deal significant damage to the meaning of NATO and cause its enemies to make new calculations about the costs of attacking member states.

Under Trump the US could theoretically devote less money to NATO’s budget, or be less inclined to participate in the installation of defense equipment or deployment of troops in Eastern Europe to deter Russia from pulling a repeat of what did with Crimea. All of this in turn makes Russia more relaxed and gives it more leverage over eastern European states.

“Russia has been annoyed and threatened with the US for being the world’s police, for its very expansive foreign policy that reaches into many of Russia’s traditional areas of national interest,” Mariya Omelicheva, a scholar of Russian foreign policy at the University of Kansas, says.

If Trump takes actual policy steps back from NATO, combined with his musing about the alliance’s value on the campaign trail, NATO allies might start to think that the US can’t be trusted to defend them. Then they’ll start to wonder why they bother to adhere to this alliance in the first place — essentially calling one of the pillars of the post-war world order into question.




Moscow.media
Частные объявления сегодня





Rss.plus




На фоне массовой раздачи паспортов России таджикам очередного русского лишают гражданства и отправляют на судилище в Таджикистан

Вывод песни для продвижения в Импульсе Яндекс Музыка.

Вскрылись жуткие подробности смерти 24-летней звезды «Дома-2»: несколько дней мертвая пролежала в квартире

Стирание исторических следов как признание цивилизационного банкротства


Report: Liverpool decision hands advantage to Man United in midfielder pursuit

Report: AC Milan’s Christian Pulisic set to team up with $87 million Manchester United star

Cameroon star has said yes to Man Utd transfer but Red Devils face hurdle

OpenAI launches GPT-5, its most powerful AI yet—will it be enough to stay ahead in today’s ruthless AI race? 


Добро в каждой чашке: Елизавета Боярская, фонд «Жизнь в Движении» и сеть кофеен «Ягода» запускают авторский кофе для помощи детям с ОВЗ

В Петербурге центр города и Лахтинскую гавань связали водными круизами

В ДТП на трассе погибли двое детей и женщина

«Мысли» под прицелом: нейросетевые прорывы России — новый вызов кибербезопасности?


Steam for Chromebooks is getting axed in 2026 instead of exiting its 4-year beta

Modders are trying their hardest to add an NVMe SSD to the Switch 2, which is both impressive and something I'm not going to do

The US Air Force wants to test blowing up Cybertrucks because 'it is likely the type of vehicles used by the enemy may transition to Tesla Cyber trucks'

Находи идеальные места для персонажей-фигурок в «Is This Seat Taken?»


Овочі можусть стати розкішшю для українців


«Бежим за Мечту — Ходить»: подростки на протезах пробегут марафон в Екатеринбурге

Овчинский: работы нулевого цикла завершают в доме в Алексеевском районе

Метод Эффеком: Как перевернуть правила игры с помощью знаний

Добро в каждой чашке: Елизавета Боярская, фонд «Жизнь в Движении» и сеть кофеен «Ягода» запускают авторский кофе для помощи детям с ОВЗ




«Бежим за Мечту — Ходить»: подростки на протезах пробегут марафон в Екатеринбурге

Custom Clinic - это клиника в центре Санкт-Петербурга, где решают проблему выпадения волос комплексно и эффективно

"Динамо" Карпина упустило победу над "Сочи" в конце матча

Custom Clinic - это клиника в центре Санкт-Петербурга, где решают проблему выпадения волос комплексно и эффективно


Владимир Ефимов: С января в Москве построили 22 административно-деловых здания

Компания «КЕНГУРУ.ПРО» подписала соглашение с сетью премиальных фитнес-студий PRO TRENER

ЛПК Сибири: Агротехнические уходы требуют четкого планирования и своевременного выполнения

Мария Багреева: начался прием заявок на конкурс «Лидеры закупок Москвы»


Кудерметова победила Ламенс и прошла во второй круг турнира WTA 1000 в США

"Это невозможно есть": Звезда тенниса из России раскритиковала кухню Парижа

Александрова пробилась в третий круг турнира в Цинциннати

Александрова снизилась в рейтинге в борьбе за титул WTA


Опасные и неблагоприятные явления на реках, озерах и водохранилищах Российской Федерации по состоянию на 9 августа 2025 г.

В России полностью изменят систему «Госуслуг»

Компания «КЕНГУРУ.ПРО» подписала соглашение с сетью премиальных фитнес-студий PRO TRENER

На синей ветке метро запустили новый «Состав будущего»


Музыкальные новости

«Навсегда в наших сердцах»: Нюша рассказала о потере бабушки

Mash: врачи просят Александра Розенбаума бросить курить после пневмонии

Би-би-си выпустит документальный фильм об Оззи Осборне

МакSим показала фигуру на яхте, а беременная Муцениеце отдыхает с сыном в Крыму



Охранник из аэропорта Внуково стал моделью

Добро в каждой чашке: Елизавета Боярская, фонд «Жизнь в Движении» и сеть кофеен «Ягода» запускают авторский кофе для помощи детям с ОВЗ

"Динамо" Карпина упустило победу над "Сочи" в конце матча

От Чехова с мангустами до встречи “Варягов”: что скрывают стены Московского вокзала Тулы


ГК «КОРТРОС» — в числе лидеров страны по объему ввода жилья

Новости в мире музыки

ЦСКА смёл «Рубин» за полчаса и провёл лучший матч при Челестини

Квартира, дача, 50 млн: кому достанется наследство актера Ивана Краско


Российский рэпер сжег кабриолет BMW прямо на сцене

Кино на Белой даче: какие фильмы чеховский музей покажет в августе

У Крымского моста скопилась очередь из 1,1 тысячи автомобилей

Процесс сошел с рельсов // Верховный суд определил пересмотреть дело о наезде Kia на трамвай


Генсек НАТО предположил возможный итог встречи Трампа и Путина

Путин обратился с приветствием к участникам форума «Машук»

Медиа сообщили о предполагаемой локации встречи Путина и Трампа на Аляске

Bloomberg сообщает, что ЕС хочет провести переговоры с Трампом до встречи с Путиным





«Бежим за Мечту — Ходить»: подростки на протезах пробегут марафон в Екатеринбурге

Компания «КЕНГУРУ.ПРО» подписала соглашение с сетью премиальных фитнес-студий PRO TRENER

«Бежим за Мечту — Ходить»: подростки на протезах пробегут марафон в Екатеринбурге

Custom Clinic - это клиника в центре Санкт-Петербурга, где решают проблему выпадения волос комплексно и эффективно


В Киеве сделали заявление о территориальных уступках

После «успешных» переговоров с Вэнсом в Киеве вновь отвергли мирные инициативы


"Динамо" Карпина упустило победу над "Сочи" в конце матча

Компания «КЕНГУРУ.ПРО» подписала соглашение с сетью премиальных фитнес-студий PRO TRENER

Московское «Торпедо» и «Спартак» из Костромы обменяются голами, «Пюник» возьмет три очка. Экспресс дня 11 августа: прогноз и ставка

Росгвардейцы обеспечили безопасность фестиваля ЛИГА ТРИАТЛОНА & IRONSTAR МОСКВА 226 2025.


В Минске считают, что интервью Лукашенко превратили в пропагандистский опус

Интервью Лукашенко на "Беларусь 1" стало примером пропагандистской одержимости



Собянин: Окончен основной этап благоустройства набережной в Покровском-Стрешневе

Сергей Собянин: С 2011 года в Москве привели в порядок более 90 км набережных

Собянин: с 2011 года в Москве привели в порядок более 90 км набережных

Собянин: Еще два направлявшихся к Москве БПЛА нейтрализованы силами ПВО


Преимущества применения озона для очистки воды

Было-стало. Какая улица вела на Москву, а привела в заповедник

Москва: Новая эра зарядных станций для электромобилей с поддержкой инвесторов

США предостерегают о возможной крупной чрезвычайной ситуации


Участник Парада Победы смолянин Александр Ржавкин

Врач Плинатус рассказала, какие прививки нужно сделать ребенку перед школой

Мария Багреева: начался прием заявок на конкурс «Лидеры закупок Москвы»

Росгвардейцы обеспечили безопасность фестиваля ЛИГА ТРИАТЛОНА & IRONSTAR МОСКВА 226 2025.


Льготные ипотеки на Дальнем Востоке активно получают участники СВО и сотрудники ОПК

В Алтайском крае не будут проводить проверку на предмет чрезмерного роста тарифов на ЖКУ

без заголовка

Чёрный день календаря. 8 августа: Архангельская трагедия. Как ошибка пилота погубила рейс Як-40


Сергей Карякин: 7 августа на поезде из Москвы в Симферополь выехали участники специальной спортивно-образовательной программы «Шахматный лагерь Сергея Карякина», которая стартует в Международном детском центре «Артек»

Прогноз погоды в Крыму на понедельник

Прогноз погоды в Крыму на 10 августа

Подросток на Мersedes сбил пешехода на трассе в Керчь


Компания «КЕНГУРУ.ПРО» подписала соглашение с сетью премиальных фитнес-студий PRO TRENER

Врач Плинатус рассказала, какие прививки нужно сделать ребенку перед школой

В России полностью изменят систему «Госуслуг»

Владимир Ефимов: С января в Москве построили 22 административно-деловых здания












Спорт в России и мире

Новости спорта


Новости тенниса
Анна Калинская

Теннисистка Калинская пробилась в третий круг турнира в Цинциннати






ЛПК Сибири: Агротехнические уходы требуют четкого планирования и своевременного выполнения

Росгвардейцы обеспечили безопасность фестиваля ЛИГА ТРИАТЛОНА & IRONSTAR МОСКВА 226 2025.

Врач Плинатус рассказала, какие прививки нужно сделать ребенку перед школой

На синей ветке метро запустили новый «Состав будущего»