Добавить новость
ru24.net
Все новости
Декабрь
2015

China's laughably overhyped quest to displace the dollar as a reserve currency, explained

0
Vox 

China this week received official status from the International Monetary Fund as the issuer of one of just five globally influential currencies that are used to peg the value of the IMF's Special Drawing Rights (SDR). If this sounds boring to you, Neil Irwin at the New York Times spices things up by suggesting that this "akin to what happened about a century ago, when the United States dollar was gradually supplanting the British pound as the predominant currency for global trade and finance," a move that "was a crucial piece of the nation’s rise to superpower status." Similarly, Matt O'Brien at Wonkblog raises the prospect that China "might be like the U.S. 100 years ago": poised to displace us as the world's financial hub, just as we were poised to displace Britain at the dawn of World War I.

The good news for those of you who don't know what any of this is about is that it's honestly not nearly as important as these stories are making it sound. I personally think the mechanics are interesting, but in terms of global economic conditions Paul Krugman rightly says, "This is not much more than a minor change in accounting, with trivial economic implications." Ben Bernanke compares it to an elementary school teacher putting a gold star on a piece of properly completed homework. He says it's a move that "confers no meaningful additional powers or privileges on China."

So honestly feel free to stop reading this article right now (though I would appreciate you sharing it on social media), unless you happen to be in the market for a detailed exploration of the nuances of something that isn't that important.

What's the slightly longer version?

Here are the key bullet points about this story:

  • The value of SDRs is specified in terms of a "basket" of internationally significant currencies.
  • Previously, the Chinese RMB was not in the basket. Now it will be.
  • SDRs are themselves not that important to the world economy.
  • Which currencies are in the basket is not that important to how SDRs work.
  • But membership in the SDR basket is symbolically important, serving as a kind of IMF seal of approval for foreign countries to hold your currency as a "reserve" instrument — a fancy finance term for when a country tries to save money by stockpiling foreign currency.
  • But it really is just symbolism, there is no particular indication that countries are about to start holding Chinese money as a major part of their reserves.
  • What's more, there's no particular economic significance to which currencies are used as international reserve currencies.
  • But there is arguably symbolic significance to being used in this way — it shows that foreign governments consider you credible and important.
  • So if this matters to the Chinese government, it matters either because they are misinformed or because they are primarily after a symbolic token of national prestige.
  • It is entirely possible that the Chinese government doesn't particularly care much about this whole issue, which would be sensible of them.

So what's an SDR?

At the heart of this unimportant story is a deservedly obscure economic instrument known as a Special Drawing Right.

IMF member states (which these days is basically all countries) hold SDRs that are allocated (i.e., created out of thin air) to member states in a manner proportionate to their payments to the IMF. The value of an SDR is determined in terms of a basket of currencies. Back in the early 1990s, for example, an SDR was 40 percent dollars, 21 percent German marks, 11 percent French francs, 17 percent Japanese yen, and 11 percent British pounds. More recently, SDRs have been 41.9 percent dollars, 37.4 percent euros, 9.4 percent yen, and 11.3 percent pounds. Now China is joining the club, and future SDRs will be 10.92 percent yuan, with the weight accorded to other currencies diminished accordingly.

You can't actually do anything with an SDR other than swap it for one of its component currencies. Consequently, countries generally don't do anything with their SDRs, and SDRs play no significant functional role in the economy.

The IMF does, however, use the SDR as its unit of account when scoring its own books. And a number of other international organizations — ranging from the Economic Community of West African States to the Islamic Development Bank — follow their lead in this regard. Actual business is conducted in local currencies, in dollars, or maybe in euros or yen or whatever else is convenient. But for accounting purposes, the SDR is a nice neutral choice.

If this doesn't sound important to you, then you are correct. As Berkeley economist Maurice Obstfeld recounts in his excellent overview of the SDR, they were created to solve a problem peculiar to the economic conditions of 1969. At the time, only gold or dollars — which were convertible to gold — could be used for international economic transfers. But there wasn't enough gold and dollars to go around. The idea was that "even though SDRs are not money, they could be used, like demonetized gold, to settle international claims between central banks." Could this have worked? Maybe. But the world will never know, because just a few years later Richard Nixon ended the convertibility of dollars into gold, and the entire gold-based system and the gold-related problem the SDR was supposed to solve went away.

So then what's a reserve currency?

Countries sometimes want to stockpile foreign currency — or financial assets that are denominated in foreign currency — for a variety of reasons.

One, as Obstfeld recounts, is as a form of "self-insurance" against financial crisis. The IMF itself is supposed to be able to help crisis-stricken countries with loans, but getting an IMF loan requires agreeing to an IMF-written structural adjustment program. Keeping a few billion dollars under the pillowcase is a small price to pay for national sovereignty.

Another is genuinely as a savings device. Intelligently managed oil exporting countries, for example, know that spending 100 percent of any given year's oil revenue would be a mistake. The global price of oil goes up and down from year to year, and the reserves generally don't last forever. So oil-rich countries generally stockpile a bunch of foreign currency during good times to have something to help ride out the lean years.

Last, a country can amass foreign currency reserves as a kind of accident. For years, Americans were buying tons of stuff that was made in China, and the Chinese government didn't want this to drive up the price of Chinese currency. Consequently, China needed to buy and hold some dollar-denominated financial assets. That's how it wound up buying so many US government bonds, leading to a lot of misinformed commentary about the existence of some kind of Chinese debt bomb.

When it comes to foreign currency reserves, in principle any currency would work. In practice, you want a currency that is widely used so that if you need to sell your currency in the middle of a panic you will find customers. You would also like the currency to be tied to a credible legal system, a transparent political system, and open financial markets. Basically you want American dollars, and then you might want to hedge a bit with euros and yen and British pounds especially if you happen to do a lot of business with those countries. The main thing, though, is that you want a currency that other people will want — it's a basic coordination game. So for a long time the currency that everyone wanted was the British pound. Then after Britain's financial resources were exhausted by two gigantic global military conflicts, the main default global reserve currency became the US dollar.

In theory, the dollar could be supplanted by Chinese money someday. But not only would a lot of institutional, legal, economic, and political changes need to happen in China for this to make sense but you would also need some equivalent of the world wars to erode the United States from its current position.

What does this have to do with SDRs?

Nothing. There is literally no causal relationship between inclusion in the SDR basket and emergence as a dominant global reserve currency. The SDRs themselves are counted as a form of foreign currency reserve, but that's an unrelated issue to whether anyone really uses the SDR's component currencies as a reserve asset. The euro has been in the SDR basket since its inception, and it's not all that widely used as a reserve currency because there's just no reason for anyone to switch.

Okay, but being used as a reserve currency must be awesome, right?

You often hear this, generally from Europeans, who sometimes complain that the United States enjoys an "exorbitant privilege" from the dollar's reserve currency status that allows us to get away with running large trade deficits.

But this is not true. Australia has run bigger trade deficits for longer than the United States, nobody holds Australian dollars as a reserve currency, and Australian governments are not wasting their time trying to convince anyone to do it.

The reason Australia can always run trade deficits is ultimately not that mysterious. Australia is a rich country with a credible legal system and a stable political order that also — thanks to immigration — has a substantially higher population growth rate than other advanced economies. That makes Australia well-suited to receive a net inflow of private investment money from the rest of the world. All this also applies to the United States, though to a lesser extent, and so we also can sustain large trade deficits.

Meanwhile, even if it really were true that being a global reserve currency made it easier for you to run a trade deficit, it's clear that the Chinese government doesn't want to run a trade deficit. On the contrary, it rather infamously intervenes in foreign exchange markets to try to ensure it runs a trade surplus to bolster its exporting industries.

So why the hype?

China has an ongoing and active program to send people to the moon.

Once upon a time, the United States and the Soviet Union were engaged in a high-profile "space race" to accomplish precisely this. It is not entirely clear to me why the superpowers became fixated on this moon goal, since there was never any indication that anything of value was on the moon. But it happened. And the US won. And then we sent a few more astronauts to the moon. And then having proved our point (whatever the point was), we stopped bothering. China is a large and important country whose large population and middling income combine to make it a major power on the world stage.

Consequently, the Chinese government is doing a bunch of "major power on the world stage" type of things. One of those is trying to send people to the moon. Lobbying the IMF to get into the SDR basket is a lot cheaper than sending people to the moon.




Moscow.media
Частные объявления сегодня





Rss.plus




Оркестр полиции Республики Сербской впервые выступит на фестивале «Спасская башня» в Москве

Рэпер Баста открыл свой ресторан в Marins Park Hotel Екатеринбург

Игровые терминалы в ТЦ: союз ради будущего

Аукцион за часть дачи Пугачевой опровергли


Las 'Guerreras del Agua' se dan un baño de bronce en el Mundial de Singapur

Adil Rami carga contra Lamine: "No puedo ni verlo, que le den..."

La UFC anuncia un mes de octubre mayúsculo

Brit Who Fought Usyk Calls For Daniel Dubois To ‘Leave The Sport’ After Staying Down In Rematch


Отдых в отеле, джип и частный дом: какие взятки мог получить экс-губернатор Тамбовской области

Летний Петербург. Сад--трасформер на Московской площади.

В лобовом столкновении кроссовера и грузовика погибли два человека

«Деловые Линии» сократили сроки авиаперевозок по более чем 4400 направлений по России


Краткая биографическая справка о центральных персонажах Mafia: The Old Country

'I destroyed months of your work in seconds' says AI coding tool after deleting a devs entire database during a code freeze: 'I panicked instead of thinking'

Microsoft warns of 'active attacks' on its government and business server tech, with one cybersecurity expert claiming that they should 'assume that you have been compromised'

Brütal Legend is free in honor of Ozzy Osbourne, but only for 666 minutes



«Каникулы с Росгвардией» проходят в регионах Центральной России

В Третьяковке на Кадашевской набережной открылся концертный зал

Оркестр полиции Республики Сербской впервые выступит на фестивале «Спасская башня» в Москве

Оркестр полиции Республики Сербской впервые выступит на фестивале «Спасская башня» в Москве




Оркестр полиции Республики Сербской впервые выступит на фестивале «Спасская башня» в Москве

Время в деталях. Как антиквары Барнаула сохраняют историю

Работа над качеством: цифровой аудитор внедрен на горячей линии московских судов

В студии Детского радио прошла церемония гашения почтовой марки


Движeниe нa Зaпοpοжьe: pοccийcκиe вοйcκa ɜaшли в Ϲтeпнοгοpcκ

В Ярославской области регистрировалось три групповых очага кори

На МКАД в Москве произошло массовое ДТП, движение затруднено

Адвокат Грачева заявила, что Седокову хотят привлечь к уголовной ответственности


«Следующая остановка — Монреаль!» Потапова полетела в Канаду для участия в «тысячнике»

Медведев пробился в четвертьфинал турнира в Вашингтоне

Медведев победил У Ибина и вышел в четвертьфинал турнира ATP в Вашингтоне

Медведев сравнил матчи с Опелкой в Нидерландах и США


Жители Хакасии подали 80 заявок на Слёт Всемирного фестиваля молодёжи

В Ярославской области регистрировалось три групповых очага кори

Врач Соловьева: прокрастинация может быть симптомом депрессии

На МКАД в Москве произошло массовое ДТП, движение затруднено


Музыкальные новости

Алексей Учитель снимает фильм о композиторе Дмитрии Шостаковиче

Наталья Фриске показала дочь в костюме врача и поведала о своем самочувствии

Аукцион за часть дачи Пугачевой опровергли

В Петербурге требуют заблокировать сайты, продающие липовые билеты в Мариинку



В Третьяковке на Кадашевской набережной открылся концертный зал

В депо «Чита» будет установлен первый цифровой весоизмерительный комплекс системы подачи песка под колесные пары локомотива

«Деловые Линии» сократили сроки авиаперевозок по более чем 4400 направлений по России

«Каникулы с Росгвардией» проходят в регионах Центральной России


В Смоленской области пройдёт IT-фестиваль «Мой Бизнес. Табтабус 2025»

Водитель Audi сбил трех пешеходов, переходивших дорогу на западе Москвы

Путин дал указание рассмотреть проблемы онкологии в Архангельской области.

Инсайдер Карпов: "Спартак" предложил "Динамо" Мх за Пальцева 250 млн рублей


Водитель Audi сбил трех пешеходов, переходивших дорогу на западе Москвы

На МКАД в Москве произошло массовое ДТП, движение затруднено

В столичном главке Росгвардии проведён смотр спецтехники

Несколько автомобилей столкнулись на внешней стороне 92-го км МКАД


В сентябре Путину будет представлена обновленная программа строительства кораблей для ВМФ.

Соболезнования в связи с авиакатастрофой в Амурской области выразили зарубежные лидеры

У Путина есть роскошный подарок для Китая: США схватились за голову, узнав о нем

"Ультиматум Трампа: потенциальные последствия для Путина"


Новый штамм коронавируса "стратус" фиксируют в Москве с мая

Депздрав: новый штамм коронавируса «стратус» фиксируют в Москве с мая

Депздрав Москвы: новый штамм коронавируса "стратус" фиксируют в Москве с мая

Штамм коронавируса "стратус" захватил 22% всех вирусных заболеваний в Москве




Utrace запускает услугу по валидации IT-систем для фармацевтического рынка

Фитнес-марафоны на паузе: суд продлил домашний арест блогеру Лерчек

Пластический хирург Софья Абдулаева: подтяжка груди нитями - эффективно ли это

Новый штамм коронавируса "стратус" фиксируют в Москве с мая


Британский журналист: Зеленский - мелкий жулик и крыса, которому «недолго осталось» в этом мире


«Каникулы с Росгвардией» проходят в регионах Центральной России

Две трети россиян считают, что спортсмены зарабатывают слишком много

"Монсон о спортсменах, которые меняют гражданство в сложный период для России"

Игровые терминалы в ТЦ: союз ради будущего


Лукашенко заявил, что в Белоруссии «на всякий случай» готовятся к войне

Лукашенко с иронией отнесся к санкциям, запрещающим ему въезд в Эстонию

Лукашенко посоветовал не злить его и не допускать падежа в животноводстве

Лукашенко поделился мнением о самой идеальной профессии.



Сергей Собянин поздравил москвича — победителя международной олимпиады по физике

Мэр Москвы: Улучшим транспортную доступность Южного и Северного Бутова

Сергей Собянин. Главное за день

Собянин: Около 10 тыс. москвичей начали переселение по реновации этим летом


Бурмистров: лисы могут появляться на улицах Москвы в период расселения

6 лет вместе. В Москве пройдет выставка, посвященная пандам Жуи и Диндин

В центре внимания: CorpSoft24 вошел в рейтинг крупнейших ИТ-компаний России

Исследование выявило снижение инвестиций в экологически чистую энергетику США.


Рекордный массовый женский нетворкинг: событие от «Мир Бизнес Мам»

В Ярославской области регистрировалось три групповых очага кори

На МКАД в Москве произошло массовое ДТП, движение затруднено

Адвокат Грачева заявила, что Седокову хотят привлечь к уголовной ответственности


70 участников СВО в Архангельске показали мотивацию выше госслужащих — Цыбульский

В Архангельске началось обучение бойцов СВО, сообщил Цыбульский.

Путин дал указание рассмотреть проблемы онкологии в Архангельской области.

В Нарьян-Маре из-за холодов возобновили подачу отопления в дома


В Симферополе на базе «Клинического госпиталя для ветеранов войн» функционирует гериатрический центр для пожилых людей с возрастными нарушениями

Лавандовое поле горит в Симферопольском районе Крыма

"Россия дала мне возможность быть счастливым": Джефф Монсон в Крыму

Россияне выбирают Крым для отдыха с детьми – названы города-лидеры


На МКАД в Москве произошло массовое ДТП, движение затруднено

Игровые терминалы в ТЦ: союз ради будущего

В МЧС предупредили москвичей о жаре +30 градусов 25 июля

Жители Хакасии подали 80 заявок на Слёт Всемирного фестиваля молодёжи












Спорт в России и мире

Новости спорта


Новости тенниса
WTA

Болбой раздавил спасенного теннисисткой Cаккари жука на турнире WTA-500 в США






Рекордный массовый женский нетворкинг: событие от «Мир Бизнес Мам»

Игровые терминалы в ТЦ: союз ради будущего

Математика Савватеева возмутило заявление о "лишних" учителях

На МКАД в Москве произошло массовое ДТП, движение затруднено