Hedge Funds On Pace to Badly Underperform the Markets in 2019
The pain kept coming for hedge funds in 2019: if they weren’t being killed off, they were bleeding cash or wringing out dismal returns.
The industry is now on track to record more closures than launches for a fifth straight year, a blow to a market that once minted millionaires at a heady pace. More than 4,000 funds have been liquidated in the past five years, according to data compiled by Hedge Fund Research Inc.
Billionaires Louis Bacon and Jeffrey Vinik were among veterans who rocked the more than $3 trillion industry this year by handing back capital to clients. Many found themselves out of step with the longest running bull market in history, while others faced investor revolt or couldn’t raise enough to stay in the game. Some had just been doing it for too long, and wanted out.
“Everything has to come to an end, sometime,” Stephen Roberts wrote in a letter to clients this month to announce his decision to close the Horseman European Select fund. “I have found myself looking at a different path ahead.”
Investors are pulling money at an accelerated pace as high fees and mediocre returns send them searching for yield elsewhere. They’ve yanked $81.5 billion this year through November, more than twice the amount for the whole of 2018, according to eVestment data.
As for returns, there’s little to cheer there. While the S&P 500 delivered a 28% gain this year through November, the Bloomberg Equity Hedge Fund Index only managed 10%.
The following hedge funds closed or turned into family offices this year:
| Firm/Fund/Unit | Portfolio Manager/Founder |
|---|---|
| Amplitude | Karsten Schroeder |
| Argentiere | Deepak Gulati |
| Arrowgrass | Nick Niell |
| Atreaus Master Fund | Todd Edgar |
| BlueMountain flagship & quant funds | Andrew Feldstein, Stephen Siderow, Perry Vais |
| Cambridge Square | Marco Barrozo |
| Citadel’s Aptigon unit | Eric Felder |
| CJW Capital* | Chris Wheeler |
| Duane Park | Andrew Goodwin, Dominick Maggio and David DePaolo |
| Eikoh Research | James Pulsford |
| Everett | Kelly Hampaul |
| HBK Capital’s Quant Fund | |
| Horseman European Select | Stephen Roberts |
| Lone Pine’s Juniper | Stephen Mandel |
| Macrosynergy Trading Fund | Nikos Makris |
| Margate | Samantha Greenberg |
| Moore Capital** | Louis Bacon |
| Nektar | Patrik Olsson |
| Oceanwood European Financial | Julian Garcia Woods |
| Peace Bridge | Christopher Buonafede and Michael Pinelli |
| Port Meadow | Carl Vine |
| Precocity | Nick Tiller |
| Protege Partners & Mov37 ^ | Jeffrey Tarrant |
| Rubicon Global Fund | Paul Brewer |
| Sandell | Thomas Sandell |
| Sator Square | Manuel Blanco |
| Stream Asset Management | Paul Andiorio |
| Stone Milliner | Jens-Peter Stein, Kornelius Klobucar |
| Teza Master Fund | Mikhail Malyshev |
| Three Stones | Jong Beum Kim |
| Trias L/S | Kilian Kentrup |
| Vinik Asset Management | Jeffrey Vinik |
| * Shelved plans to start ** Returning money in its three main funds ^ Closed two funds and returned capital following the death of founder Tarrant |
—With assistance from Suzy Waite, Katherine Burton, Katia Porzecanski, Hema Parmar, Saijel Kishan, Melissa Karsh, Bei Hu and David Ramli.
More must-read stories from Fortune:
—2020 Crystal Ball: Predictions for the economy, politics, technology, etc.
—Why you actually may want to buy “bears” in a bull market
—5 CEO exits that sum up the memorable business year that was 2019
—The Decade in IPOs: What 6 offerings tell us about going public in the 2010s—How blockchain will shake up the financial world
Don’t miss the Term Sheet, Fortune’s newsletter on deals and dealmakers.