Curious cases of alleged lotto bettors winning multiple times explained

(1st UPDATE) PCSO officials present a logical explanation for Senator Raffy Tulfo's query on how a supposed lotto player won 36 times in just the second half of 2023

MANILA, Philippines – The curious cases of alleged lotto bettors winning multiple times in just a few months last year – an unlikely event given the low statistical probability of winning the lottery – has been clarified. 

In a Senate games and amusement committee hearing on Monday, March 18, Senator Raffy Tulfo presented four questionable instances of supposed bettors winning the lottery multiple times in the second half of 2023. 

The most unbelievable instance is the case of “Person B” – who supposedly won 36 times from July to December 2023 with total winnings of P8.325 million. In the months of August and November, the supposed bettor won P225,000 nine times each month. (Editor’s Note: An earlier version of this story reported that “Person B” won 43 times. The correct number is 36 times.)

In the case of “Person A”, the supposed bettor won 14 times with total winnings of P1.026 million; “Person C” won 13 times and collected P378,000; and “Person D” won 17 times and collected P561,966. 

What made these cases more questionable was the fact that the supposed winners did not give their tax identification number (TIN) when they claimed their prizes.

Philippine Charity Sweepstakes Office (PCSO) officials led by General Manager Mel Robles clarified during the hearing that all these multiple winnings involved “digit games,” such as 2D (2 digits) lotto and 3D (3 digits) lotto, where the chances of winning are higher than in jackpot games such as 6/42, 6/45, 6/49, and 6/58. They said that no winner has won more than once for jackpot games.

In 2D lotto, a bettor selects two numbers from 1 to 31. The player can bet from P10 to P500, and the numbers must match the winning combination in exact order. The PCSO has three draws of 2D lotto daily. 

In 3D lotto, a bettor selects numbers from 0 to 9 from each column, and the numbers must be in the same order as the winning combination if playing straight. Bettors can choose lucky picks to get their numbers. A bet of P500 wins P225,000.

Claimants, not bettors

Lauro Patiag, PCSO assistant general manager for general services, said those involved in these so-called “multiple winnings” were “claimants” who collected the prizes on behalf of bettors.

In rural areas, he said it has become a practice for the winner of the lower-tier games to approach the lotto agent and ask the agent to claim the prize. 

“We have a [PCSO] branch office in each province, but we have lotto agents in far-flung areas. For practical reason, nakiki-claim sila (they ask a favor to claim the prize) because they trust him,” Patiag said. 

In the case of “Person B,” Missel Hamak, branch manager of the PCSO’s Agusan del Norte Branch, identified the claimant as a lotto agent – an owner of a lotto outlet – who lives in Butuan City, Agusan del Norte in Mindanao.

Hamak said the agent acted as the claimant for bettors who placed P500 bets on the 3D lotto game. He collected the winnings for these bettors, which is why the PCSO list submitted to Tulfo has one person supposedly winning a total of 36 times; in one other instance, a player placed a P1,000 bet and won P450,000, and the lotto agent had to collect the bet in Manila.

“The main means of transportation in Butuan City is tricycle, and his lotto outlet is located 15 kilometers, very far, not accessible,” he said in a mix of Filipino and English.

Hamak said the 3D lotto game is very popular in Mindanao. The normal bet is only P10 for 3D lotto.

“Actually, sa Mindanao po, maraming sugarol, even at the time of jai-alai. Malakas po talaga [tumaya], maski may business, magtataya ng malaki-laki,” he said.

(Actually, in Mindanao, there are many gamblers, even during the time of jai-alai. Many people bet big, even though they already have a business, they bet big.)

Hamak said one reason why betting P500 on 3D lotto is preferred by gamblers is because winning this game means they can collect their prize in the province. 

If a person bets P1,000 and wins, he said the winner would have to travel to Manila to claim his prize of P450,000, so the players prefer to bet P500 since the prize would not breach the P300,000 ceiling of big winnings that have to be collected in Manila.

“[In 3D lotto] pinaka-convenient na taya na makaka-claim ka below P300,000 na hindi ka na pupunta ng Manila,” Hamak said.

(It’s the most convenient where you can claim a prize below P300,000 and you don’t have to go to Manila to claim your prize.)

In a statement on Wednesday, March 13, the PCSO said “some winners would not want to go to their branch because of added expenses, so the lotto agents would act as Good Samaritans or do it for them.” 

PCSO officials said during the over two-hour hearing that since the claimants only collected the winnings on behalf of bettors, they did not give their TIN.

Ralbert John Tibayan, representing the Bureau of Internal Revenue’s Legal and Legislative Division, said that after checking their records, the bettors in the “multiple winnings” cited by Tulfo all had TINs.

Tulfo raised the possibility, however, of the lotto agent conniving with bettors by giving them “tips.” He asked that the lotto agent who claimed winnings 36 times be summoned to the next hearing. – Rappler.com