The Turkish Detective: a familiar tale in a new setting
A keen-eyed ex-London Met detective tries his hand at solving crimes on the streets of Istanbul and soon finds the city, and its police, aren’t quite what he expected.
In the not so very distant past of British television, capers in the company of avuncular, maverick detectives were the ratings sureties around which peak-time drama schedules were built. Although viewing figures are much diminished, such shows remain plentiful.
These detective stories remain generally compliant with the wisdom that they should have two defining features. The first is an emotionally intelligent, workaholic, central character (or two) who can see what others cannot. The second is an evocative location that harbours the kinds of criminal deviance that they, uniquely, can resolve. A seeming fit for the brief is The Turkish Detective, an adaptation of the Inspector Ikmen novels by English crime writer Barbara Nadel.
Although developed by a British showrunner, the series was made by Turkish production company Ay Yapim for the multinational service Paramount+. Curiously, however, it was given no UK release by the streamer but is instead airing on BBC2 and iPlayer, having been recently acquired by the corporation.
The show begins with the arrival at Istanbul airport of Mehmet Süleyman (Ethan Kai), an officer “transferred” from London, as if Turkey were merely an administrative district in the global empire of the British Constabulary. Although Süleyman claims to have had the “wrong name, wrong skin, wrong religion” for the Met, he is surely there to offer an identifiable vantage for the British viewer.
At first, he mistakes his new boss Çetin İkmen (Haluk Bilginer) for a driver, even attempting to arrest him – but this is merely an orchestrated rookie error to demonstrate how here in Istanbul, they do things differently. Süleyman has a faltering grasp of Turkish – no impediment to joining the homicide team – so conversations are held in English whenever he is around.
Before long, he is speeding off to crime scenes and turning up clues that nobody else has spotted. Such activity enables a warming tourist gaze at artfully composed wide-angled vistas of Istanbul skylines, teeming side streets, stray cats, the sun-drenched glint of the Bosporus strait and, well, more cats.
Of course, it is not Süleyman but Ikmen who is the pre-requisite maverick. This is signalled by his twinkly eyes, chain smoking and the kind of petty disputes with his superior in which television investigators tend to specialise. “Haven’t I taught you anything?” he asks his sergeant Ayse (Yasemin Kay Allen). “Go with your gut and to hell with what everyone else thinks?” she replies, in what sounds like a direct quote from the gospel according to Frost, Lewis, Luther, Grace and just about every titular TV detective there ever was.
A similar self-consciousness dogs the presentation of Istanbul as exotic, enticing and quirky, but seldom threatening. The team are rarely in any real jeopardy, and their caseload of murders (of influencers, rap impresarios and rubbish collectors) offers little to unsettle a tourist.
Instead, and increasingly, the narrative is taken up by laboured, unenigmatic backstories for each officer. Süleyman has several of these, mostly concerning his ongoing secret investigation into an incident involving a former girlfriend. He also has an estranged Turkish father, about whom there can be no real interest, not least because they are reconciled before the first case is even solved.
Ikmen’s domestic life is more intriguing, at least to begin with. His second wife gives birth to a new baby and his older children threaten to go off the rails, encouraged, in part, by his neglect. However, here as elsewhere, too much time is devoted to telling rather than showing, and the secondhand discussion of his family crisis begins to wear thin.
At one point, Ikmen shares his woes with the wealthy father of a victim, but only after spotting on his bookshelf a volume of poetry – not from any Turkish tradition, but by Dylan Thomas. Later, this comes in handy when the man lapses into unconsciousness and Ikmen reads, urging him to “rage, rage, against the dying of the light”.
You cannot help but feel for Bilginer, who has commendably grizzled charisma, but an actor needs lines with more wit than sentiment to make this kind of role work. Given the otherwise deft direction by Niels Arden Oplev, the series’ imperialist premise and clunky scripts are really to blame for its shortcomings.
On this note, it is apt to recall a speech from 30 years ago by the late television writer, Alan Plater, who suggested that the “proper, decent future for world television” should be one in which “I should tell you the stories from my backyard and you should tell me the stories from yours”. Imagine Plater’s dismay at The Turkish Detective and the realisation that for all the lauded “globalisation” of television, we only get to hear the stories which resemble those we have already told.
Looking for something good? Cut through the noise with a carefully curated selection of the latest releases, live events and exhibitions, straight to your inbox every fortnight, on Fridays. Sign up here.
Helen Piper does not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organisation that would benefit from this article, and has disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond their academic appointment.