Bachelor fans are convinced newly single Colton Underwood is dating Madison Prewett after flirty Instagram exchange
BACHELOR fans are convinced Colton Underwood is dating Peter Weber’s ex, Madison Prewett, just weeks after his split from Cassie Randolph. The former Bachelor leading man and the religious contestant from Pilot Pete’s season have caused romance speculation after a series of flirty Instagram exchanges. Both Madi, 24, and Colton, 28, are self-proclaimed Christians and […]
BACHELOR fans are convinced Colton Underwood is dating Peter Weber’s ex, Madison Prewett, just weeks after his split from Cassie Randolph.
The former Bachelor leading man and the religious contestant from Pilot Pete’s season have caused romance speculation after a series of flirty Instagram exchanges.
Both Madi, 24, and Colton, 28, are self-proclaimed Christians and have been vocal about how important faith is in their lives.
Additionally, the pair have also each expressed their choice to save themselves while appearing on the ABC reality series.
Madison told her ex Peter, 28, the week before Fantasy Suites that she was saving herself for marriage.
The Alabama native ultimately left the pilot after she found out he was intimate with other women that week – only to get back together but later breakup for good.
Similarly, the former NFL player revealed to season 14’s Bachelorette, Becca Kufrin, that he was a virgin at the time of filming in 2018.
Later that year, he went on to become The Bachelor, with many calling him “The Virgin Bachelor” after he openly talked about abstaining from sex during his season.
He dated his season’s winner, Cassie, 25, for over a year but announced they split last month.
In recent days, Colton and Madison have left friendly comments on each other’s social media pages that have fans hoping they are now an item.
Last week, the Auburn alum shared a video about offering “encouragement” through online Christian community, Faith Social.
Colton quickly commented “Amen!” on his rumored-girlfriend’s post, to which she responded with a hands up emoji.
A couple days later, the San Diego Chargers athlete posted a picture as he drank a cup of coffee as the sun sets on the beach behind him.
He captioned the post: “Glorifying and enjoying God is a higher priority than maintaining a tidy, structured life.
“Give up your striving to keep everything under control—an impossible task and a waste of precious energy.”
Madi showed her nod of approval and wrote “So good!” on the post.
The pair have also double-tapped a series of each other’s pictures on Instagram.
Members of Bachelor Nation think their like-minded morals would make them the “perfect couple.”
“Can we stop beating around the busy and just date already?” one admirer urged.
Another eager fan encouraged: “Get married to this Godly woman!! You guys would be perfect together.”
“Okay I might be acting like a mom but I think you and Madi are perfect together,” someone told the reality star.
Hundreds of others also said in the comments section that they “ship” the pair and pushed Colton to “go get his girl.”
Most Read in Entertainment
On May 29, Colton and Cassie revealed they broke up 18 months after they first began dating on the ABC reality show.
The former couple each announced the shocking split on Instagram in emotional posts that vowed they’ll continue to be friends.
Madi has not publicly dated anyone since her split from Peter two days after the season finale of The Bachelor in March.