I took on the DWP and won back £22k after huge benefit error – even after I was told I was WRONG
A DISTRAUGHT pensioner has won his months-long fight with the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) after being told he owed thousands of pounds – with the help of The Sun.
Last year, we revealed how Robert Vincent was told he would have to repay an eye-watering £22,000, after the government department said there were errors in his application for pension credit.
Pension credit is a benefit which helps those over state pension age (currently 66) and on a low income with the cost of living.
The benefit tops up their weekly income to a minimum of £201.05 for single pensioners and £306.85 for couples.
Mr Vincent was put on a plan that would have meant he was paying the money back until he was 86.
The 75-year-old was forced to cancel all his insurance policies just to afford food after the DWP said he had to repay £258.72 every four weeks until February 2030, then £105.17 until it was paid off completely.
At the time Mr Vincent disputed the repayment plan but accepted he would have to pay it back if he had genuinely made an error.
The DWP had blamed him for providing the incorrect income when he first applied for the benefit six years ago.
The Sun first contacted the DWP on Mr Vincent’s behalf in September and asked it to investigate his claim, at which point it maintained that he had declared the wrong pension income figure.
But now it’s emerged that the fault lies with the DWP and not the retiree, from Porthcawl in South Wales.
After almost five months of back and forth, it has admitted it was their error after a staff member misheard Robert’s pension income during his application over the phone.
In a letter to Mr Vincent from the DWP, seen by The Sun, it said: “You asked us why we used the amount of £934.84 a year rather than the actual amount of £9,034.84 as your occupational income.
“Regrettably, this was due to our error. The person you spoke to on the telephone on April 4, 2017 misheard you and thought that you had said the occupational pension you were receiving from Derbyshire County Council was £934.84 a year.”
The DWP also acknowledged that Mr Vincent had spotted this discrepancy and flagged it to them several times between 2017 and 2023, but no action was taken.
“I would like to offer my apologies for our errors in your case,” it added.
The DWP said it will no longer be asking Mr Vincent to pay the money back, and has also refunded him the £976 he has repaid since September.
Mr Vincent said: “It’s great news the DWP has finally admitted it made errors.
“Many thanks to The Sun for all your help in getting this resolved.”
Mr Vincent is now seeking compensation for the distress this has caused him.
Thousands of benefits claimants have been asked to pay back money they were awarded in error over the past few years – in some cases because of mistakes by the DWP.
The latest government figures show around £330 million was overpaid in pension credit in the year to October 2022.
The Sun has contacted the DWP for further comment.
What if I’m asked to repay money and it wasn’t my fault?
If the DWP believes you have been overpaid a benefit, it will write to you detailing what happened and how much you owe.
You can ask it to reassess your case if you don’t agree with its decision.
In your response, ask how it made its decision, as well as for a “mandatory reconsideration”.
You should then get another letter with the outcome of the reconsideration. If you still don’t agree, you can appeal the decision at a tribunal.
You can also make a complaint about the customer service you receive from the department.
Say you’re making a formal complaint and ask to initiate its complaints procedure, either in writing or over the phone.
A complaint resolution manager should look at your case and issue a final response.
It’s a good idea to keep hold of any correspondence when you make a benefit claim in case you have any issues down the track.
For example, if there is an error and you spot it, make sure to raise it with the relevant department and keep a record of this correspondence.
If you aren’t satisfied with the response to your complaint, you can write to the independent case examiner for another opinion, but you must do so within six months of receiving a response.
Read our full guide on how to complain like a pro here.
Do you have a money problem that needs sorting? Get in touch by emailing money@the-sun.co.uk.
Plus, you can join our Sun Money Chats and Tips Facebook group to share your tips and stories.