Our dumbed-down debate distracts us from reforms that could attract consensus.
Refugee resettlement in the United States is as politicized as it has been in generations. That is a shame, because our current dumbed-down debate distracts us from reforms that could attract consensus support, decreasing security risks while ensuring the program’s viability.
To detractors, the current system endangers American lives and undermines democracy; the program’s architects are well-meaning, but naïve and dismissive of security concerns. For proponents, resettling refugees is a moral obligation and an unalloyed national good; critics are frightened, if not xenophobic and selfish.
Following the September 18 terrorist attacks in New York, New Jersey, and Minnesota—and news reports that perpetrators Ahmad Khan Rahami and Dahir Adan were immigrants—the internet seethed with both denunciations and formulaic defenses of refugee resettlement in the United States.
In response to the administration’s September 15 announcement that it plans to resettle 110,000 refugees in fiscal year 2017, including a “significantly higher number” of Syrian refugees (than the approximately 13,000 resettled in FY 2016), some members of Congress may again oppose full funding of resettlement-related Department of State and Department of Homeland Security operations.
At least thirty-one governors have now come out in opposition to resettlement of Syrian refugees, including Texas Governor Greg Abbott, who announced September 30 that Texas (which has the second largest program in the country) would end its cooperation with the federal program.
People on both sides are guilty of misstatements and exaggerations. Since we seem to be headed toward another round of rhetorical artillery from both sides, here are eight common positions taken by defenders or detractors of refugee resettlement, and why they are misguided:
1. “The United States Must Resettle (Its Fair Share of) Refugees.”
Заместитель управляющего ОСФР по г. Москве и Московской области Алексей Путин об индексации работающим пенсионерам
Филиал № 4 ОСФР по Москве и Московской области информирует:
2,5 млн жителей Москвы и Московской области получили пособия по временной нетрудоспособности с начала 2024 года
Сотрудники Росгвардии задержали нетрезвого водителя в подмосковных Люберцах
Сотрудники Росгвардии задержали нетрезвого водителя в подмосковных Люберцах
Risk of Rain 2 creators weigh in on Gearbox's first DLC without them: 'It's great to see new content for the game, but it's hard to see growing pains of the new team in real time'
Risk of Rain 2's creators, along with 'many other' devs from Hopoo, have been snapped up by Valve—which means the end of the studio's unannounced game
1 млн предрегистраций на Nigoriri Angels on Stage и релиз на этой неделе
Court locks in Bungie's $4.4 million win against Destiny 2 cheat maker, refuses request for a new trial
Заместитель управляющего ОСФР по г. Москве и Московской области Алексей Путин об индексации работающим пенсионерам
Росгвардейцы принимают участие в обеспечении правопорядка в период проведения Единого дня голосования в Подмосковье
Выставка «Я ты мы другое» в музее-квартире И.Д. Сытина
Филиал № 4 ОСФР по Москве и Московской области информирует:
2,5 млн жителей Москвы и Московской области получили пособия по временной нетрудоспособности с начала 2024 года
Филиал № 4 ОСФР по Москве и Московской области информирует:
Гражданам Москвы и Московской области, получившим тяжелые производственные травмы, выданы автомобили марки «Лада Гранта»
МВД: в Москве задержали подозреваемого в убийстве сотрудника АЗС
Филиал № 4 ОСФР по Москве и Московской области информирует:
Гражданам Москвы и Московской области, получившим тяжелые производственные травмы, выданы автомобили марки «Лада Гранта»
Филиал № 4 ОСФР по Москве и Московской области информирует:
Гражданам Москвы и Московской области, получившим тяжелые производственные травмы, выданы автомобили марки «Лада Гранта»